Tips & Toddler Meal Prepping For Picky Eaters (With Recipes)

Toddler meal ideas for picky eaters don't have to be a struggle. Dive into our guide filled with practical tips, science-backed strategies, and delicious, kid-friendly recipes.

This content is for informational purposes only and not intended as medical advice. Please see our disclaimer page for more information.

Jump to:

• Understanding Picky Eating
• The Science Behind Fussy Eaters
• Top Strategies for Picky Eaters
• What to Avoid With Your Picky Eater
• 🍴Meal Ideas for Picky Eaters
• 🍴Healthy Snacks Ideas
• 💭Quick Tips for Worried Parents
• My Experience As a Mom of 3
• Dealing with Dietary Restrictions
• When to Talk to Your Doctor
• 🥦Key Takeaways
• The Last Bite: Summing Up Our Picky Eater Journey
• Information Source

Hello, fellow parents! If you're reading this, chances are you've got a little one at home who turns up their nose at anything that isn't mac 'n cheese or nuggets. Trust me, I've been there. As a mom of three and a health science expert, I've navigated the tumultuous seas of toddler meal times more times than I can count.

Each of my kids has gone through their own picky eating phase. My oldest son, an adventurous eater in his early years, became more selective as he grew. My middle son, sensitive to textures and flavors, required a lot of patience and small exposure to new foods. And my youngest, a food lover from the start, still has his moments of hesitation.

Through all the trials and tribulations, I've learned that feeding a picky eater is less about the food itself and more about the approach. It's about creating a positive, stress-free environment where kids feel comfortable exploring new tastes and textures. It's about understanding their unique preferences and working with them, not against them.

In this blog post, I'll share some of my favorite strategies along with kid and toddler meal ideas for picky eaters. These tips and strategies are backed by both personal experience and scientific research. I'll also share some kid-friendly meals that have been a hit in my household. So, whether you're a seasoned parent or a newbie, I hope you'll find some helpful tips and inspiration here. Let's get started!

Understanding Picky Eating

If you've ever sat across from a child of any age who's refusing to eat anything green on their plate, you know that picky eating is a real challenge. But what exactly is picky eating, and why does it happen?

Picky eating, fussy eater, or selective eating, is when a child refuses foods often or eats the same meals over and over. Picky eaters can reject food based on its texture, color, smell, or shape. And while it can be a source of stress for us parents, it's a common part of childhood development (1).

Children are naturally curious and cautious. When it comes to food, this caution can manifest as picky eating. They might refuse a food because it's new and unfamiliar, or because they had a bad experience with it in the past. It's their way of exploring the world and asserting their independence (2).

Now, as a mom of three, I've had my fair share of mealtime standoffs. Each of my kids had their own picky eating phase, and each required a different approach. But through it all, I've found that patience, creativity, and a little bit of science can go a long way. And remember, it's okay to not be perfect, being a parent is hard work and sometimes we have hard moments. Don't be too hard on yourself!

In the next sections, I'll share some toddler meal ideas for picky eaters, along with strategies that have worked for my family. But remember, every child is unique. What works for one might not work for another. The key is to keep trying, keep experimenting, and keep the mealtime environment positive and stress-free.

The Science Behind Fussy Eaters

As a health science expert and neuroscientist, I've always been fascinated by the science behind behaviors, and picky eating is no exception. Why do some kids turn up their noses at broccoli while others can't get enough? The answer lies in a complex interplay of genetic, environmental, and psychological factors.

1. Genetic factors: Research shows that children's food preferences are influenced by their genetic makeup (3). Some kids are genetically predisposed to be more sensitive to certain tastes and textures. This can make them more likely to reject foods that are bitter, sour, or have a strange texture.
2. Environmental factors: Children learn about food from their surroundings - from their parents, siblings, and even their peers at school. They're more likely to try a new food if they see others enjoying it (4). This is why eating meals as a family can be such a powerful tool in encouraging picky eaters to try new foods.
3. Psychological factors: Children are naturally cautious about new foods. This caution can sometimes manifest as picky eating. They might refuse a food because it's new and unfamiliar, or because they had a bad experience with it in the past (5).

Understanding the science behind picky kids and food can help us develop effective strategies to address it. In the next section, I'll share some of the top strategies for dealing with picky eaters, based on both scientific research and my own experience as a mom.

"Parents, take note! The science suggests that instead of focusing on your child's 'picky eating' behavior, it's more beneficial to model healthy eating habits, particularly fruit and vegetable consumption. Your eating habits can have a significant influence on your child's dietary intake. So, let's lead by example and show our kids how delicious and enjoyable fruits and vegetables can be!"

Top Strategies for Picky Eaters

When looking for new toddler meal ideas for picky eaters, it cna often feel like a culinary chess match. But don't worry, here are some of the top strategies, backed by both science and my own experience as a mom:

Introduce new foods often:

Research shows that repeated exposure to new foods can increase children's acceptance of them (6). It might take a few tries (or even a few dozen tries) but don't give up. Keep offering different foods alongside their favorite safe foods, and over time, they may start to accept them.

Pair New Foods With Favorites:

One of the strategies that worked well for my middle son was pairing new foods with his favorites. This can take some of the stress away from trying something new. For example, if your child loves pasta, try adding a few pieces of a new vegetable to the sauce, or on the side.

This also helps with your weekly meal plan because you won't be stressed about having to make separate meals. Just ensure you have some safe familiar foods and go ahead and enjoy the recipes and flavors you normally love. I often tone down the spice level to accommodate but I find meal times way more enjoyable if I feel satisfied with the recipe as well!

Serve Small Portions:

Serving small portions of both new and safe food can make mealtime less intimidating for your little one. Plus, it's easier to ask for more of something they like than to deal with the pressure of finishing a large serving of something they're unsure about

Involve Kids in Cooking:

Kids are more likely to try a dish if they've had a hand in making it. This is a strategy I often use with my kids, especially my oldest, and it's always a hit. Plus, it's a great way to spend quality time together and teach them valuable life skills. If possible bring them to the grocery store and let them pick out some of their first time foods. This not only gives them a sense of control but also fosters their natural curiosity!

Serve Meals Family-Style:

Let your child serve themselves at meal times. Bring all the dishes you are serving to the dinner table and let your child choose and serve everyone eating. This gives them a sense of control and makes them more likely to try new foods. Remember, it's our job to provide a variety of healthy foods, but it's their job to decide what and how much to eat.

Eat Together as a Whole Family:

As I mentioned earlier, kids learn a lot of behaviors by observation. Eating meals together with the entire family can encourage picky eaters to try new foods (4). It doesn't have to be at every meal or even every day but the consistency of eating together is what counts.

For my family, we prioritize getting together for family dinners and it is a great way to connect at the end of a busy day. If you are just starting this practice I encourage you to make kid-friendly dinners to start. cook up some classic kid favorites, put on your favorite music, and just enjoy the time together. Remember the important part is for your child to see and observe you eating along with them.

Educate Your Kids About Nutrition:

Young kids are naturally curious, explain to them why eating veggies and fruits is healthy. And why eating balanced meals is important (you can check out this post on how to ensure you make balanced meals here).

This not only satisfies their curiosity but also helps them understand the connection between food and their bodies. It's a great way to foster a positive relationship with food from a young age and understand what makes healthy recipes.

Involve Your Kids in Grocery Shopping and Cooking:

This is one of my favorite tips because it gives your child some control over what they eat. Start with a simple recipe with healthy ingredients and let your child help you choose what to make.

Remember, every child is unique, and what works for one might not work for another. The key is to be patient, keep the mealtime environment positive and stress-free, and keep trying different strategies until you find what works best for your child.

What to Avoid With Your Picky Eater

While it's important to know what to do when dealing with the pickiest eater, it's equally important to know what not to do. Here are a couple of things to avoid, based on both scientific research and my own experience:

• Forcing Children to Eat Certain Foods: It can be tempting to turn meal times into a power struggle, but forcing children to eat certain foods can backfire. Research shows that pressuring children to eat can lead to food aversion and even more picky eating (5). Instead, aim to create a relaxed and positive mealtime environment where a variety of foods are offered, and your child is given the autonomy to choose what and how much to eat.

• Using Food as a Reward or Punishment: Using food as a reward or punishment can lead to unhealthy eating habits later in life (7). Try to keep food neutral. Praise your child for trying new foods, but avoid rewarding them with sweets or punishing them by taking away dessert.

Remember, the goal is to create a positive, stress-free mealtime environment where your child feels comfortable exploring new tastes and textures. It's a journey, and there will be bumps along the way. But with patience, creativity, and a little bit of science, you can help your picky eater develop a healthy relationship with food.

Top tip: Remember our strategy for food exposure? It's all about offering a specific food often but without the stress or pressure. The goal is to make the food familiar and accessible, not to force your child to eat it. So, keep serving that broccoli (or any other new food), but let your child take the lead on whether they eat it.

🍴Meal Ideas for Picky Eaters

Now that we've covered some strategies for dealing with picky eaters, let's dive into our best meal prep ideas and easy meals for picky eaters, also great for older kids. These are easy toddler meals that have been a hit in my household, and I hope they'll be a hit in yours too!

1. Balanced Dinner Platter:

One fun way to introduce new food is to serve them on a 'snack' tray as finger foods! I love making a dinner platter for my boys and instead of snack foods I add in meatballs, sliced veggies, olives, pickles, plain pasta, dipping sauce, and fresh fruits, the possibilities are endless. It is a great way to use up leftovers!

This is my favorite picky eating recipe and a simple way to ensure you create balanced meals. It makes for a very easy dinner and is perfect for a movie night or picnic idea.

2. Crispy Tofu Nuggets:

These Tofu Nuggets are a hit with kids and tofu skeptics alike! It's a great beginner recipe for getting more tofu into your kid's diet, especially for those lovers of chicken nuggets.

This easy recipe uses simple ingredients and is made gluten and dairy free, perfect for all dietary needs. The recipe makes for easy meal prepping and the nuggets freeze well. They're a fun and healthy alternative to traditional chicken fingers and make a great toddler meal for picky eaters

3. Sesame Orange Tofu:

Sesame Orange Tofu is another great way to introduce tofu to your little one. Tofu is a nutritious food that is packed with proteins, minerals, and vitamins. The tofu is crispy, providing a nice texture, and the sauce is sweet yet savory. Plus, the sauce can be served on the side for dipping, which can make the meal more fun for your child.

4. Simple Homestyle Chili:

Our easy Homestyle Bean Chili is always a favorite in my household. I like to serve it with tortilla chips, turning it into a fun dip. If your kids like fries then use them as a fry dip! It's a great way to sneak in some veggies and plant-based protein. You can find the recipe here.

5. DIY Tacos:

Tacos are a great meal for picky eaters because they allow your child to pick their own toppings. This can make them feel more in control and more likely to try new things. Plus, they can help assemble their own taco, which can make the meal more fun and engaging.

We love having rice, black beans, crispy chickpeas, shredded lettuce, diced cucumbers, tomatoes, and avocado in separate bowls on the table. Then we let out kids pick their toppings. For the more adventurous eaters, use this creamy Ceaser creamy Caesar dressing for added flavor! Best of all you can tailor this meal to your family's preferences.

Pressed for time? Simply steam the rice and while it cooks drain canned black beans, and chop up the veggies. Then assemble at the table! Simple but it does the trick!

6. Nut Butter and Jelly Sandwiches:

A classic that's easy to make and usually a hit with picky toddlers and young children. But don't just stick with the classic peanut butter, swap out the PB for sunflower seed butter, pumpkin seed butter, or almond butter. You can also choose a jam made with no added sugar or try using honey as an alternative.

And since kids love finger foods, try cutting the sandwiches into thin slices. Serve with whole-grain bread for added nutrition and pair it with a smoothie or crispy carrot sticks or apple slices for a more balanced meal.

7. High Protein Quinoa Meatballs

My favorite meal prepping meal for my picky eater. Our flavorful Quinoa Meatballs are loaded with veggies but boast a meaty texture. Serve them with your child's favorite pasta or as finger foods with a dip. Let your child experiment with dipping them into tomato sauce or just explore the texture.

8. Cheese Quesadillas:

Another popular and fun recipe for fussy toddlers that can be easily modified. Try building on this recipe by adding some very finely chopped spinach for a hidden serving of veggies. Start by adding small portions and increase slowly as you continue to expose your child to this recipe.

Serve with a side of salsa, guac, or hummus for dipping, and cut the quesadillas into thin slices or different shapes for easy dipping! If your child is old enough, let them choose their toppings. Kids are always more interested in finger foods as it allows them more control.

9. Pasta with Peas and Olive Oil:

Simple, nutritious family meals that are easy to whip up. You can use whole-grain pasta for added fiber. Serve the pasta as the main meal and add a side of raw veggies.

10. Burrito Bowls with Rice and Beans:

In our home, we have a mixed bag when it comes to burritos - one burrito enthusiast and two who would rather leave it. One strategy I've found helpful is to serve deconstructed burrito bowls to my other 2 kiddos. This way, each child can personalize their bowl with their preferred toppings and the prep is the same. This sense of control can often make them more open to experimenting with new ingredients.

11. Quick Scrambled Eggs:

An easy healthy breakfast that also works well for dinner! We love making this Tofu Scramble Recipe because it is packed with healthy fats and protein. Tofu scramble is a great alternative if you have a child with an egg allergy.

Pair it with some avocado toast or wrap it into a breakfast burrito for a well-balanced meal. My older son loves this wrapped into a burrito for dinner or school lunches.

🍴Healthy Snacks Ideas

Snack time can be a great opportunity to introduce your fussy toddler to new foods and different food textures. And I find it equally important to have great meal prepping snacks for our picky eaters.

Here are some toddler meal ideas for picky eaters that are perfect for those in-between meal moments when your little one needs a quick, nutritious bite.

Snack Platters:

These are super fun and exciting for kids of all ages. Try and pair a bunch of colors and add favorites and new foods to help entice your child.

Fruit Kabobs:

These are fun to eat and you can use any fruit your child likes. You can also include some vegan cheese cubes for added variety.

Hummus and Veggie Sticks:

Hummus is a great source of protein and it pairs well with any veggie your child likes.

Smoothies:

Just like with meals, smoothies can be a great way to sneak in some fruits and even veggies. You can add a scoop of vegan protein powder or a spoonful of nut butter for added protein. For little kids or as a fun alternative add less water for a thicker smoothie option. Place into a bowl and top with your kid's favorite granola bar or fruit to help entice them to try new smoothie flavors.

Vegan Yogurt with Granola:

There are many delicious vegan yogurts available now. Top it with some granola or stir in some protein powder and fruit for a balanced snack.

Vegan Cheese and Crackers:

There are also many vegan cheeses on the market now. Pair with some whole-grain or gluten-free crackers for a satisfying snack.

Roasted Chickpeas:

These are crunchy, protein-packed snacks that you can flavor in many different ways. We love this crispy chickpea recipe and use it often in salad or pasta, or as a snack.

Vegan Energy Balls:

These are usually made with nuts, oats, and dates, and they're a great source of energy. They have a lot of beneficial fats, vitamins, and minerals and for extra protein, you can add in a scoop of unflavored protein powder. Find our favorite recipe here.

Remember, the key to introducing new toddler meals for picky eaters (or child), is to do it gradually and to pair new foods with their favorites. And most importantly, keep the mealtime environment positive and stress-free. Make family meals enjoyable!

My Experience As a Mom of 3

As a mom of three, I've had my fair share of experiences with picky toddlers and young children! And finding toddler meals for picky eaters is no easy feat! Each of my kids had their own unique eating habits and preferences, and each required a different approach.

In his early years, my oldest son was always eager to try different flavors and textures. However, as he grew older, his palate became more selective. We later discovered that he has autism and food allergies, which added another layer to our mealtime dynamics. Despite this, his early exposure to a variety of textures and flavors helped him navigate his picky eating phase with relative ease. Adapting his favorite recipes to accommodate his dietary restrictions was a journey filled with learning curves. His eating habits continue to be a dynamic challenge, but as a mom, I'm constantly learning, evolving, and adapting my approach to best support him and create healthy meals.

My middle son was probably the most picky of the three. He is very sensitive to textures and flavors and needs a lot of small exposures before he starts to like a specific food. Initially, there was more stress around mealtimes but after a bit of research, a lot of the strategies for picky eaters worked with him.

My youngest son has been a food lover from the start. He does go through phases where he doesn't want to eat much or isn't into a specific food, but I think we learned so much with my middle and older son that we were able to avoid a lot of the power struggles and battles around mealtime and food.

What I have learned about raising my boys is that what works for one might not work for another. The key is to keep trying, keep experimenting, and keep the mealtime environment positive and stress-free.

Dealing with Dietary Restrictions

When your child is a picky eater, dealing with dietary restrictions can add an extra layer of complexity when you are looking for toddler meals for picky eaters. But don't worry, it's absolutely possible to cater to dietary restrictions and still provide a variety of tasty and nutritious meals for your child.

Speaking from my own experience as a mom and a food blogger who's all about gluten-free and vegan recipes, I've navigated dietary restrictions and picky eating more times than I can count. So, let me share a few tips that might just make your journey a little smoother:

1. Focus on What They Can Eat: Instead of focusing on the foods your child can't eat due to dietary restrictions, focus on the foods they can eat. There are plenty of delicious and nutritious gluten-free and vegan foods out there.
2. Get Creative with Substitutions: There are many great substitutes for common allergens. For example, you can use gluten-free grains like quinoa or rice in place of wheat, or use flaxseeds or chia seeds as an egg substitute in recipes.
3. Involve Your Child in Cooking: This can be especially helpful when dealing with dietary restrictions. When your child is involved in the cooking process, they can see all the delicious foods they can eat, despite their dietary restrictions.
4. Try New Recipes: There are plenty of delicious gluten-free and vegan recipes out there that are kid-friendly. Trying new recipes can help keep meal times exciting and ensure your child gets a variety of nutrients.

When to Talk to Your Doctor

While picky eating is a common phase that many children go through, there are times when it might be a good idea to seek professional help. If your child's picky eating is causing significant stress in your family, or if you're concerned that it's affecting their growth and development, it might be time to talk to your pediatrician or a registered dietitian.

Here are a few signs that it might be time to seek professional help:

• Your child is losing weight or not gaining weight appropriately.
• Your child is eliminating entire food groups or has a very limited range of accepted foods.
• Meal times are causing significant stress or conflict in your family.
• You're concerned about your child's nutritional intake.

If you're ever in doubt, it's always a good idea to seek professional advice.

The Last Bite: Summing Up Our Picky Eater Journey

When looking for toddler meal ideas for picky eaters it can feel like a daunting task, but remember, you're not alone. Many parents face the same challenges, and there are strategies that can help. From understanding the science behind picky eating to learning what to do and what not to do, to trying out new toddler meal ideas for picky eaters, there are many ways to navigate this journey.

Remember, every child is unique, and what works for one might not work for another. That's why it is good to have many meal prepping recipes for picky eaters!

The key is to be patient, keep the mealtime environment positive and stress-free, and keep trying different strategies until you find what works best for your child.

And most importantly, don't forget to enjoy the journey. Yes, there will be bumps along the way, but there will also be moments of joy and discovery. So keep exploring, keep experimenting, and keep the faith. You've got this, mama!

I hope you found these tips and toddler meal ideas for picky eaters helpful! And you enjoyed some of the meal prepping for picky eaters. If you have any questions or if you'd like to share your own experiences or tips, please leave a comment below. And if you try any of the meal or snack ideas, I'd love to hear how it went!

Information Source

1. Zhang, M., van der Horst, K., Fries, L. R., Yu, K., You, L., Zhang, Y., Vinyes-Pares, G., Wang, P., Ma, D., Yang, X., Qin, L. Q., & Wang, J. J. (2017). Perceptions of food intake and weight status among parents of picky eating infants and toddlers in China: A cross-sectional study. Appetite. 108:456-463.
2. Wardle, J., & Cooke, L. (2008). Genetic and environmental determinants of children's food preferences. British Journal of Nutrition. V99 (S1): S15-S21.
3. Kauer, J., Pelchat, M. L., Rozin, P., & Zickgraf, H. F. (2015). Adult picky eating. Phenomenology, taste sensitivity, and psychological correlates. Appetite, 90, 219-228.
4. Wardle, J., & Cooke, L. (2008). Genetic and environmental determinants of children's food preferences. British Journal of Nutrition.
5. Galloway, A. T., Fiorito, L., Lee, Y., & Birch, L. L. (2005). Parental pressure, dietary patterns, and weight status among girls who are “picky eaters. Journal of the American Dietetic Association, 105(4), 541-548.
6. Birch, L. L., McPhee, L., Shoba, B. C., Pirok, E., & Steinberg, L. (1987). What kind of exposure reduces children's food neophobia? Looking vs. tasting. Appetite, 9(3), 171-178.
7. Birch, L. L., Fisher, J. O., & Davison, K. K. (2003). Learning to overeat: maternal use of restrictive feeding practices promotes girls' eating in the absence of hunger. The American Journal of Clinical Nutrition, 78(2), 215-220.